Madagascar vs Saint Barthélemy Comparison
Comprehensive comparison across 9 categories and 44 indicators
Geography and Demographics
Economy and Finance
Quality of Life and Health
Education and Technology
Environment and Sustainability
Military Power
Governance and Politics
Infrastructure and Services
Tourism and International Relations
Comparison Result
Superior Fields
Superior Fields
* This score reflects overall livability and quality of life, not just economic or military strength
GDP Comparison
Total GDP
GDP per Capita
Comparison Evaluation
Madagascar Evaluation
While Madagascar ranks lower overall compared to Saint Barthélemy, specific areas demonstrate competitive advantages:
Saint Barthélemy Evaluation
Detailed Comparison
The Longest Lives in This Comparison Belong to the Smallest Island
A child born on Saint Barthelemy can expect 84.5 years, the longest life expectancy in this comparison. Madagascar reports 64. The gap is not a mystery of climate or diet. It belongs to institutions. Saint Barthelemy is a French commune with a hospital, a European health system and a population small enough to be tracked, and Madagascar is a country where the same services reach a fraction of the people. Longevity follows the machinery around it, and the machinery is expensive to build and dull to maintain.
The island covers 21 square kilometers. Madagascar covers 587,041. On 21 square kilometers, a clinic, a pharmacy and a doctor are minutes apart, and the whole population lives inside a single municipality. Madagascar must place the same services across highlands, coasts and a dry south, and staff them where the staff may not want to live. Small size makes good services cheap to deliver and easy to supervise, and it makes the place easy to run and hard to diversify, which is the trade every microstate accepts.
Forty-Two Thousand Dollars a Head and a 320 Million Dollar Import Bill
GDP per capita is 42,000 dollars in Saint Barthelemy and 595 dollars in Madagascar. The island earns its money from a specific kind of visitor: people who arrive for a week, stay in a villa, eat in restaurants and leave. That trade supports a standard of living that would be impossible on the resources the island actually holds. Madagascar has more resources, more people and more room, and it has not converted them into comparable incomes for most households. What separates them is the price of what each place sells.
The trade balance makes the dependence visible: minus 320 million dollars in Saint Barthelemy and minus 1.2 billion dollars in Madagascar. For the island, the deficit is the shape of an economy that imports nearly everything it consumes and pays for it with services. For Madagascar, the deficit is tied to fuel, machinery and manufactured goods, and it is smaller next to the size of the economy. Both places run on goods they do not make, at very different scales. Neither is close to paying its own way in goods.
Almost No Unemployment and Almost No Room to Grow
Unemployment is 2 percent in Saint Barthelemy and 2.92 percent in Madagascar, closer than anyone would expect from two such different economies. The similarity is accidental. On the island, work is seasonal and often informal, and the official rate counts only those who register as looking. In Madagascar, the rate is low because most people cannot afford to be unemployed and take whatever work appears. Two healthy-looking numbers can describe two very different labor markets, and only one of them involves a choice. The other involves a household that cannot wait.
The resident population is 11,414, and the Madagascar total is 32,740,678. A population that size makes government personal: the mayor knows the families, the school knows the surnames, and a new business needs a handful of employees rather than a hiring drive. It also means there is no labor reserve. A single closure or a bad season cannot be absorbed by moving workers to another district, because there is no other district. Everything depends on the season and on the boat. That is the price of a place where everybody is needed.
The Same Density Pays for Wages and Bandwidth
The minimum wage is 1,937 dollars in Saint Barthelemy and 55 dollars in Madagascar. The island figure is the French national floor, applied to a labor market built on hospitality, construction and household services. It sets a standard that local employers must meet or leave. The Madagascar floor is set for a formal sector that employs a small share of workers, and most wages are decided by negotiation, season and need rather than by statute. A floor is only a floor when someone can enforce it.
Bandwidth on Saint Barthelemy runs at 85.5 Mbps; in Madagascar it runs at 31.31 Mbps. The island advantage comes from a compact customer base and a short cable route to Europe and North America. The Madagascar network reaches a scattered population across a landmass that makes every kilometer of fibre expensive. Bandwidth, like everything else here, is easier to supply when the customers are close together and able to pay. Geography sets the ceiling, and prices decide how close to it a network can climb from below.
Data Disclaimer: Projected data (future years) are estimates based on mathematical models. Actual values may differ. Learn about our methodology →
Data Sources
Comparison data is aggregated from multiple authoritative international organizations:
You must log in to comment
Log In
Comments (0)