Lebanon vs Sint Maarten Comparison
Comprehensive comparison across 9 categories and 44 indicators
Geography and Demographics
Economy and Finance
Quality of Life and Health
Education and Technology
Environment and Sustainability
Military Power
Governance and Politics
Infrastructure and Services
Tourism and International Relations
Comparison Result
Superior Fields
Superior Fields
* This score reflects overall livability and quality of life, not just economic or military strength
GDP Comparison
Total GDP
GDP per Capita
Comparison Evaluation
Lebanon Evaluation
Sint Maarten Evaluation
While Sint Maarten ranks lower overall compared to Lebanon, specific areas demonstrate competitive advantages:
Detailed Comparison
The richer island buries its people earlier, and that inversion is the argument
Seventy-six point seven years is how long the average Sint Maarten resident lives, and 78.1 is how long the average Lebanese lives. The island is richer by more than eleven times per person, at 36,700 dollars against 3,200, and it still buries its people earlier. That single inversion unsettles the usual story about the Caribbean and the Levant. Money buys clinics, clean water and safer roads, and Sint Maarten has some of all three. What it does not buy is an economy that leaves anyone undisturbed long enough to grow old comfortably.
The economy is one product. Sint Maarten hosts 373,000 visitors a year, roughly eight for every resident, and earns 300 million dollars from them against 8.2 billion in Lebanon. Lebanese tourism is larger in absolute terms and spread across ski slopes, ruins, religious sites and nightlife; the island has beaches, a cruise terminal and duty free shops. Concentration is efficient until it is not. One hurricane, one weak aviation season or one virus empties the hotels, and there is no second industry to absorb the people who worked in them.
A holiday island of thirty-four square kilometres has nowhere to put its own people
Sint Maarten covers 34 square kilometres, less than the footprint of a large airport, and packs 1,228.3 people into each one against 557 in Lebanon. Density at that level is not a planning preference; it is the only option available. Everything the island needs arrives by ship or plane, including food, fuel and much of its labour. Lebanon at least grows olives, grapes and vegetables in the Bekaa. The island grows nothing, so every shortage becomes a price on a shelf rather than a harvest that failed.
Wages reflect the arrangement. The minimum wage is 830 dollars a month against 100 in Lebanon, and unemployment is 11.5 percent against 11.49, as close to identical as two labour markets ever get. Those figures say something uncomfortable: the island pays eight times the Lebanese floor and still leaves the same share of its people without work, because a tourism economy hires seasonally, imports specialists and keeps a wide low-wage base. A higher floor raises the price of a room. It does not create a second industry.
Sint Maarten is cheap to visit and expensive to inhabit
Prices on the island are set for people on holiday. Electricity costs 0.31 dollars a kilowatt hour against 0.09 in Lebanon, and much of it runs air conditioning that the climate makes non-negotiable. Inflation is 3.2 percent against 80 in Lebanon, so the comparison is unfair in one direction: the island does not suffer currency collapse. But a stable currency and imported groceries mean a resident pays European prices on a Caribbean wage. Tourists see a bargain. The people serving them see a rent they cannot cover.
Basic services hold up better than the island gets credit for. Clean water reaches 93.03 percent of residents against 92.62 percent in Lebanon, effectively the same figure, and traffic deaths run at 9.1 against 16.32. What differs is who absorbs the failures. On Sint Maarten a burst main is a utility complaint; in Lebanon it is a household filling buckets from a private tank on the roof. Small jurisdictions fail small. Large ones fail in ways that take a decade to notice and a generation to repair.
The island runs on imported labour and imported fuel, and both bills come due
The average age is 41.8 against 28.8 in Lebanon, and retirement begins at 65 there against 60 here. Sint Maarten imports much of its workforce from neighbouring islands and further afield, which keeps the median age higher and the political conversation narrower. A worker who leaves after a season does not campaign for a new school. Lebanon has the reverse profile: an enormous cohort of young people with claims on the state and no patience left for its answers. One place manages decline. The other manages a queue.
Debt is the last surprise. Sint Maarten owes 40 percent of its output and Lebanon owes 163.15, so the poorer country is the more indebted one by a factor of four. Renewable energy supplies 1 percent of island energy against 33 percent in Lebanon, which means the holiday island depends almost entirely on imported fuel and on the price of a barrel. Abundant sun and no solar panels is less a paradox than a consequence of a tiny utility, easy diesel and nobody forcing a change.
Data Disclaimer: Projected data (future years) are estimates based on mathematical models. Actual values may differ. Learn about our methodology →
Data Sources
Comparison data is aggregated from multiple authoritative international organizations:
You must log in to comment
Log In
Comments (0)